When Jerry Brown was Mayor of Oakland, he proudly welcomed Cybergold, an internet start-up company that moved to Oakland in large part because of “the tax incentives of the Enterprise Zone.”   It was September 28, 1999.

“Cybergold’s talented workforce adds to the energy and excitement of downtown Oakland,” said Mayor Brown at an event celebrating Cybergold’s recent arrival. “Cybergold’s presence here is an unmistakable signal to other Internet start-ups that Oakland is wired and ready to go.”
Read it here.

I guess that was then and this is now, but Mayor Brown was able to build a thriving downtown Oakland because of the EZ.  Now he claims they are of no benefit to the state and should be summarily cast aside. Hmmm.

The California Association of Enterprise Zones posted this response to Governor Brown’s proposal to eliminate the Enterprise Zones:

SACRAMENTO, Calif., Jan. 11, 2011 /PRNewswire/ — The California Association of Enterprise Zones (CAEZ) understands California and Governor Brown are looking for ways to close a $28 billion budget deficit.  CAEZ believes the ultimate solution will only be achieved through strengthening California’s economy and creating jobs.  

The proposal outlined by Governor Brown to eliminate Enterprise Zones is inconsistent with policies promoting economic development, job growth and community investment.  Each Enterprise Zone is created for a limited time and represents a commitment from the state and a significant investment from local governments.  Eliminating Enterprise Zones would send the wrong message to businesses that create jobs, in essence that California is an unreliable partner not to be counted on to keep its commitments.  

“We should be doing all we can to promote economic development and create jobs locally,” said Craig Johnson, president of CAEZ.  ”Jobs generate revenue for the state.”

The uncertainty caused by proposals to abruptly change economic policies is already disrupting business decisions to expand job creating investments.  Now is not the time to abandon these partnerships and the infrastructure created at the local level through the Enterprise Zone program with private sector businesses and our local communities.  

Research has shown that Enterprise Zones help reduce poverty rates, lower unemployment, provide higher wages, increase household income levels and foster greater community investment through private-sector businesses.

“Tax increases and the elimination of these important economic development programs will only worsen California‘s unemployment rate and cause more businesses to flee to states with healthier economies and friendlier business policies,” stressed Johnson.

The California Association of Enterprise Zones (CAEZ) represents the 42 Enterprise Zones located throughout California.  CAEZ’s priority is to ensure economic growth and retaining and growing jobs in the most distressed areas of California and in communities of color.

Los Angeles is “prepared to shoulder its fair share of the responsibility” for balancing the budget, said Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa. But, “any scenario that would completely eliminate the redevelopment zones and state enterprise zones is a non-starter.”

Similarly, George Runner, the newest member of the Board of Equalization, said that raising taxes and making it tough on business isn’t a solution.

“Californians are confronted with a huge budget crisis.  The fact is for too many years we’ve been spending more money than we should.  More money has been going out than revenues coming in.” Runner said. “We can solve our budget problem and the best way to do that is by getting Californians jobs.  I’m going to be looking at this budget through that lens. I applaud the Governor for proposing difficult spending cuts.  But I can’t support proposals to hurt private sector jobs through punitive tax hikes.”

“Californians have already spoken on the issue of taxes by resoundingly rejecting every proposed tax increase on recent ballots.  A special election to hike taxes is a waste of taxpayers’ time and money. Certainly we have to make some hard decision and cuts are necessary. But if we make it harder for the private sector to create employment than this is the wrong way to go,” he said.

Eliminating enterprise zones is a big mistake, according to Runner.

“Enterprise zones are California ‘s only remaining public policy measure aimed at keeping private sector jobs in our state.  Abolishing them would be irresponsible.  Instead we should make the whole state an enterprise zone,” he concluded.

The budget released today completely eliminates all of California’s 42 Enterprise Zones.  It also takes away all prior credit carryover.  However, many see this is a starting point for negotiations.  

Assemblyman Dan Logue, R-Linda, who opposes eliminating enterprise zones, said the state needs to do more to create jobs, not less.“The governor has to realize that to create wealth and revenue, you have to give businesses a reason to develop in an area,” said Logue.

He added in the last decade, the majority of new jobs created in California came in areas where there were enterprise zones.  But because the initial budget proposal from the governor often undergoes several revisions before it’s passed and signed, Logue said, Brown may be including the cuts as a negotiating tactic.

Read the full article here.

Press release from Siskiyou County:

Siskiyou County Economic Development council responded quickly to Senator Doug LaMalfa’s request for supporting documents to ensure the continuation of the Enterprise Zone program in California.  Governor Jerry Brown announced shortly after taking office that the enterprise zone tax credits may be eliminated in the new budget.  The SCEDC provided the Senator with a letter of support and testimonials from many Siskiyou County businesses who utilize the enterprise zone program.

January 5, 2011

The Honorable Doug LaMalfa                       

CA State Senator, 4^th District

State Capitol, Room 3070

Sacramento, CA 95814

Dear Senator LaMalfa:

The Siskiyou County Economic Development Council fully supports your efforts to ensure the continuation of the California Enterprise Zone program. The Siskiyou Enterprise Zone was created on June 22, 2008. The Siskiyou County Economic Development Council administers the zone in service of its eight partner cities and the County of Siskiyou.

The SCEDC works with its partner cities, CPA’s and businesses to help them utilize the program. The program has grown from 260 employee tax credit vouchers processed in 2008 to 542 vouchers processed in 2010.   Sixty-six employers voucher employees through the SCEDC of which 61 are categorized as small companies with less than 50 employees. The 542 vouchers processed in 2010 represent 542 jobs created within Siskiyou County.  

The value of enterprise zone tax credits to Siskiyou County employers is considerable given the number of privately owned, small businesses who use the program. The dollars that they are able to reinvest in their companies are critical to the economic recovery and growth in Siskiyou County.

Sincerely,

Tonya Dowse

Executive Director

Texas is “open for business” and using its Enterprise Zone to lure California businesses looking to relocate.  Is Jerry Brown listening?

With shovel ready sites situated in an enterprise zone the Levelland Economic Development Corporation sees the new Levelland Industrial Rail Park as the key to developing a diversified local economy.  By paring this new rail infrastructure with the local skilled workforce and integrating ourselves into the wind energy logistic supply chain, Levelland can take advantage of the expanding renewable energy industry exploding throughout the region.  Levelland also offers opportunities to California businesses considering relocation or expansion by helping reduce the normal stress related with such capital intensive projects.  Our exceptional economic environment, warm weather, famous hospitality and affordable cost of living make Levelland an ideal choice for businesses looking to make a move. Texas Governor Rick Perry says, “Texas Wide Open for Business” and Levelland is a great place to enter the Lone Star State. 

Read it here.

The FTB’s January Tax News.

Newly elected Democrat Luis Alejo, of the 28th Assembly District, is lining up in favor of Enterprise Zones.  “The Enterprise Zone program should be strengthened rather than eliminated,”  Alejo said in a January 1 article in The Californian.  Although a new Democrat, Alejo was picked by Speaker Perez to be Vice Chairman of the Assembly Local Government Committee.  Alejo is also a member of the Assembly Budget Committee.  He joins JEDE committee chair Manuel Perez in voicing strong support for the Enterprise Zones.

It’s not as good as you think.  Rather the reduction is a result of the expiration of the increase contained in the 2009-2010 budget.  All personal income tax brackets will go down by .025%.  Enjoy….until the 2011 crew buts it back on the ballot.

On December 17, President Obama signed the Tax Relief, Unemployment Insurance Reauthorization and Job Creation Act of 2010.  The Tax Relief Act extended many important tax rates and programs and some have been curiously left out.   On the Federal level, the Act extends the Empowerment Zones for two more years, but not the Renewal Community Zones.  Fortunately for tax payers, the Empowerment Zone credit per employee is twice the amount of the Renewal Community credit.